Posted by: Bob Fisher | August 22, 2012

Beware the Fixed Notion When Travelling

Travelling to India was a refresher course for me in avoiding “the fixed notion” — our tendency to apply our own frame of reference to a destination.

Even though I had read about India fairly extensively, I was surprised to find myself still somewhat the “innocent abroad” when I was fully immersed in medias res India-style. Like most first-timers to India — and as is to be expected — I experienced to some extent sensory overload in this nation of over 1.2 billion people. But what really surprised me was not so much how I reacted to India but the degree to which I had come here with a preconceived notion about the country.

As travel journalists we strive of course to get the “authentic experience” and to maintain neutrality in our observations. By the way, I believe there is a qualitative difference between being “neutral” when reporting on a destination and being “objective.”

We are human sentient beings and an important component of the stories we tell is the subjective, and especially the affective. Although correct factual information is critical to travel journalism, we also strive to communicate to our listeners and readers what “it was really like”; how we felt about it, what our senses told us about the destination.

We are storytellers.

But to do this in a totally neutral fashion one should, in principle, view a new destination through fresh eyes. However, this is easier said than done; it’s not that simple leaving home at home.

We all come from somewhere and we are all products of our own cultures and cultural biases. In terms of visiting a new destination, unless we have never even heard of it or suddenly happen to find ourselves in it, we always arrive with some kind of fixed notion about the place. And fixed notions tend to be generalized, often vague, and one-dimensional.

Nonetheless, one of the delights of travelling is both confirming and experiencing first-hand that what we have heard about a place is indeed true. At the same time we begin discovering the layers of experience in a destination — that there is far more to the place than our “general knowledge” has led us to believe. As a matter of fact, the general knowledge (which contributes to the fixed notion) can even be misleading.

When I went to India, I knew I was going to a country of more than 1.2 billion people and that it would be, to some extent anyway, an overwhelming experience. For that I was prepared.

What I wasn’t prepared for was that India (alongside China) was one of the friendliest destinations to which I had ever travelled

What I had not anticipated was how quickly I would feel engaged in the Indian community in a very powerful way. As a matter of fact, India is now at the top of my list as one of the most welcoming, friendly, and captivating countries I have visited. And why shouldn’t it be? Well, because my fixed notion of a country with this many people led me to expect otherwise; that I would feel “lost in the crowd” and apart. How could my North American mind process being in the midst of a population more than 40 times the size of my own not-so-small (geographically) country? My cultural bias made me anticipate a kind of faceless society. But, happily, all that changed. From the moment I arrived, it was the individual not the masses that became my easy and delightful focal point.

My North American perception of time and order were also challenged.

Time “at home” now seems almost an obsession; time in India seemed more fluid, occasionally almost irrelevant. And although my North American brain did initially “see” disorder in Indian society, an awareness of a different kind of order gradually began to emerge.

Now the challenge is to describe that order in words; it may be something you can only experience.

Indeed as I walked the streets of  Mumbai/Bombay — including the “slum” of Slum Dog Millionaire fame — and attempted, as is my custom, to pre-write the story in my head. However, I soon learned that I had difficulty finding words from my Western lexicon that fit what I was seeing, hearing, and feeling in India.

Of course I saw poverty and pollution and they were indeed major issues, but these terms are also relative in beautiful, exotic, and intriguing India.

Relativity became a principal issue of the experience of India.

What was the lesson I learned yet once again?

It is this: we all have a bias and our cultural biases travel with us in our mental luggage. Now, a bias is not so bad; actually it’s quite normal. As I said, we all come from somewhere. There are of course negative biases (“Teenagers!”), and positive biases. (“All children have certain rights.”) And there are unintended biases that can be negative if they prevent you from really getting to know someone. (“Canadians are such nice people; polite, non-confrontational. A lot like their national symbol, the beaver. Industrious, hard-working, good swimmers, adept in the wild, have excellent dental hygiene, and are very cute.”)

So where do these fixed notions come from? From almost anywhere I suppose, and over a long period of time. Media messages of all kinds certainly play a big role, as does history, literature, mythology, politics (for sure) and our imaginations.

And because news media often tend to subscribe to the school of “if it bleeds it leads,” and promotional travel materials are essentially manufactured media, the former can create simplistic images of a destination while the latter can tend to create romanticized visions of a culture through imagery and other stylistic devices.

It is clear why the fixed notion develops. And unfortunately, cultural stereotyping is often not far behind.

The good news, however, is that because we are of necessity becoming more media competent and better equipped to “read” information contextually; we can at least reduce the possibility of letting our own presumptive experience and cultural context interfere with our understanding of other cultures we explore.

It requires effort and ’s not always easy, but isn’t that why we like to travel?

For more information

Visit “Incredible India” the official India tourism website.

See also “The Faces of Gujarat: Experiencing India Subliminally”.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: